Experts warn households adding wrong materials to composts

The Autumn Composting Mistakes That Could Ruin Your Garden by Spring <i>(Image: Getty Images)</i>
The Autumn Composting Mistakes That Could Ruin Your Garden by Spring (Image: Getty Images)
This article is brought to you by our exclusive subscriber partnership with our sister title USA Today, and has been written by our American colleagues. It does not necessarily reflect the view of The Herald.

As Autumn sets in and gardeners prepare their plots for the colder months, compost bins are filling up with fallen leaves, lawn clippings and food scraps. But waste experts are warning that many households are unwittingly adding the wrong materials which could stall composting, attract pests, and even harm plants come spring.

 

John Michaels, an expert from Skip firm AWM said:

 

“Autumn is one of the busiest times for composting as gardens are cleared back for winter. The challenge is that decomposition slows down dramatically in the cold, which means anything you put in the bin now will sit for longer.

“The wrong additions can upset the balance of your compost heap, leaving it smelly, pest-ridden, or even unsafe for use in the garden when spring arrives.”

 

To help households make the most of their compost this season, John Michaels has shared the seven common items you should never add to your bin in Autumn and Winter.

 

7 Things NOT to Put in Your Compost Bin This Season

1.      Cooked Food & Meat Scraps
Rots slowly in cold conditions, smells unpleasant, and attracts rats and foxes.

2.      Citrus Peels & Onion Skins
Too acidic in large amounts, slowing decomposition and harming compost-friendly microbes.

3.      Coal Ash or Treated Wood Ash
Contains chemicals and heavy metals that are toxic to plants and soil.

4.      Diseased Plants or Invasive Weeds
Winter compost bins don’t get hot enough to kill pathogens or weed seeds, risking contamination.

5.      Glossy Paper, Inked Cardboard or Packaging
Doesn’t break down properly and can leach toxins. Stick to plain brown cardboard instead.

6.      Pet Waste (Dog or Cat Litter, Droppings)
Can carry parasites and bacteria. A winter compost pile won’t kill them off.

7.      Dairy Products
Rots quickly, smells bad, and attracts pests while upsetting compost balance.

 

John then went on to reveal his top tips for composting through Autumn and Winter.

 

  1. Layer Brown and Green Materials

“Compost only works well when there’s a balance between carbon-rich browns and nitrogen-rich greens.”


This means mixing dry materials like fallen leaves, shredded cardboard or straw with fresh peelings, coffee grounds and grass cuttings. The balance keeps the pile aerated and prevents it from turning slimy or compacted.

 

  1. Chop Materials Small

“Large branches, whole vegetables or thick stems take much longer to decompose, especially in the cold.”


Breaking items down before adding them to the bin speeds up the composting process. Chopping, shredding or tearing materials creates more surface area for microbes to work on, helping the pile heat up and break down evenly.

 

  1. Keep It Covered

“Winter rain and frost can quickly cool a compost heap down and wash away valuable nutrients.”


Covering your bin with a lid or tarpaulin helps to trap warmth and keep out excess water. A stable, insulated pile allows microbes to stay active for longer, keeping decomposition ticking over through the colder months.

 

  1. Turn It Occasionally

“Without oxygen, compost piles become compacted and start to rot rather than break down properly.”


Turning your heap every few weeks introduces air, redistributes moisture, and keeps the contents from going anaerobic. Even in winter, this simple step prevents slimy patches and helps your compost stay healthy.

 

  1. Choose the Right Location

“Where you place your compost bin makes a big difference to how effective it is during the colder months.”


Positioning the bin in a sunny, sheltered spot helps it retain heat and avoid waterlogging. Keeping it off bare ground with a pallet or bricks can also prevent the base from becoming too damp, making it easier to manage throughout winter.

 

“Composting is one of the most effective ways to reduce household waste while creating nutrient-rich fertiliser for your garden.

By knowing what not to include, and following a few simple steps, you can keep your compost healthy all through autumn and winter, ready to use when planting season begins in spring.”

Get involved
with the news

Send your news & photos